不是吧!屎忽宝voted第一!
By richie...Filed under: Film下午在The Movie Blog看到的这则消息, 引述如下:
The BBC are carrying the story from Empire Magazine of their latest poll. The top Directors of all time…well, up until now that is. Here’s the top ten: 1. Steven Spielberg 2. Alfred Hitchcock 3. Martin Scorsese 4. Stanley Kubrick 5. Sir Ridley Scott 6. Akira Kurosawa 7. Peter Jackson 8. Quentin Tarantino 9. Orson Welles 10. Woody Allen
一看到这个导演列表,以为是blogger自己的私人排名,再仔细一看,不是吧!bbc和Empire杂志合搞的投票活动.本能地和rico大惊小呼了一阵.怎么又来搞攀比啦?~?~此疯不可长也..嗯.. 屎提粪屎忽宝小样竟然能voted高居第一?那个PETER JACKSON也有第七位??NND不想活啦~! 如THE MOVIE BLOG的作者说到,这的确是具有极大争议性, “I’m sure we all have our own top Directors that should be there, and unless you’ve all emigrated or had your Internet connection cut off, you’re damn sure going to have something to say about the entrants on the list, and the order. So what’s wrong with these Directors? Which shouldn’t be there, and which are missing?”
有一位人兄的reply也道出本人心声:
“In what way does Spielberg beat Kurosawa? In what way does Spielberg beat Scorsese? In what.. way… does Spielberg beat Kubrick?
brain melts Spielberg is good, but not THAT good.”
我觉得,最具争议性的并非导演自身素质如何, 而是那个评选标准应该如何. 众口难调是明摆着的了. bbc搞搞阵也是明摆着的~~
哈哈.
让我排,我个人会把Orson Welles排在第一. 屎提粪能凭他的好几部高居全球box office首位的blockbusters什么猪猡记titanic可以勉强放在第十吧, Peter Jackson就肯定不能沾边的了(想都别想!),Hitchcock和Woody Allen并列第二啦!(YEAH,让我排一定得有并列~~!), 其余存在上述列表的那些导演们,也还不错,自己找地方站吧. 另外,还要呼唤那些失踪的家伙: Krystof Kieslowski, Wim Wenders, Godard…etc.etc. 你们在哪儿啊?
